When False Evidence Isn’t, or, Finality & Freedom

Who Cares?


One of the things that bothers me the most about most law enforcement officers, and most prosecutors, and many judges is that they never have any doubts.

About anything.

They don’t doubt that they’re right, when they’re wrong. They don’t doubt that they already know who did what — who committed what crime, who aided and abetted, who was an accessory after the fact, who is lying, and who might be telling the truth (usually because their story supports the officer, or DA’s, presuppositions) — even when they’ve got the wrong person. And it’s nearly impossible to change their minds by pointing to some piece of reality.

Especially if that piece of reality only comes to light after they’ve made up their minds.

[Read more...]


Hypocrisy in the Colosseum

Gladiator


I haven’t written much about the criminal law case that’s been scintillating — and then enraging — others around the country, the Casey Anthony case.

In the beginning, it was a combination of being too busy for that, and recognizing that whatever I saw on the news was likely to be sensationalized and full of erroneous and perhaps even deliberately misleading information.

As time went on, it became clear to me that there was another reason not to watch: ancient Rome was never one of my favorite “civilizations” and the Colosseum most likely would have disgusted me.

[Read more...]


Reasonable Doubt & The Lack of Political Will

Angry Mob


I spend a lot of time trying to figure out certain things. Two that I seem to spend an immense amount of time on lately are these:

  1. Is the world really becoming a more insane, or at least idiotic, place?
  2. If so, why?

I could add a third: If not, why does it seem so?

But I think the answers to the first two questions make the third question unnecessary.

[Read more...]


You Say You Want An Explanation

Imagine Reasonable Doubt


You say you want an explanation
Well, you know…
We all want to understand.
You tell me that it’s only fair
Well, you know…
We all think that’s only right.
But when you talk about the justice system
Don’t you know that you can count judges out.

[Apologies to the Beatles; none to judges.]

[Read more...]